Climate Change Committee warns UK against weakening electric vehicle targets

Advisers say weaker sales targets could put climate goals and household savings at risk, while carmakers argue the rules impose heavy costs.

Nigel Topping, second from left, stands with four other people at a COP30 meeting.
File photograph of Nigel Topping, second from left, with other participants at a COP30 Global Ambassador meeting in 2025. 10.11.2025 Global Ambassador meeting COP30 (4) (54916563496) — Aljun Alvarez for the Climate Champions Team / High-Level Climate Champions (resized and converted to WebP). CC BY 4.0.Image sourceImage licence: CC BY 4.0
WhatsAppXLinkedInEmail
Save for later

The UK Climate Change Committee has warned ministers that weakening electric vehicle sales targets could jeopardise climate goals and leave households more exposed to fossil fuel prices. Chair Nigel Topping made the warning in a letter to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander published on 18 November, POLITICO reported.

The committee argues that the targets underpin the largest share of emissions reductions to 2037 in the government’s net-zero plan. It says climate targets for 2033–2037 will be missed without alternative action on the same scale, according to the BBC.

The electric vehicle targets under review

The zero-emission vehicle mandate requires 80% of new cars sold in the UK to be zero emission by 2030 and all new cars to meet that standard by 2035. Companies that fail to meet their mandate face a potential fine of £12,000 per car, although exemptions apply.

Ministers have consulted on changes to interim targets since August. POLITICO reported that they are preparing to reduce the 2030 target, but climate minister Katie White told the outlet the previous week that the government remained committed to the mandate and had made no decision on its trajectory.

A government spokesperson said the consultation would not change its commitments to phase out new petrol and diesel cars by 2030, to make all new car and van sales zero emission by 2035, or to meet legally binding net-zero targets.

Household costs and fuel security

Topping said maintaining the rules could help a typical household save around £800 a year by encouraging a switch from petrol to electric cars. He also warned that weaker rules could damage long-term competitiveness as major export markets move to electric vehicles.

Citing a government impact assessment, he said cuts to headline targets could increase UK fuel consumption by the equivalent of up to 15 million barrels of oil a year by 2030, at a cost of more than £1 billion at current prices. The committee also warned of higher diesel costs for van drivers and risks to investment in the UK automotive sector.

Carmakers challenge the cost of the rules

Fully electric vehicles accounted for 26.6% of new car registrations in the year so far, below the 33% headline target for 2026, according to figures from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders cited by the BBC.

New AutoMotive, a transport research organisation that supports the shift to electric cars, estimates that the industry as a whole appears on course to comply with this year’s mandate once permitted flexibilities are taken into account.

SMMT chief executive Mike Hawes accused the committee of ignoring the costs of the targets. “The industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely, which is why it is unified in seeking change,” he said.

The committee’s analysis says surface transport, including cars, vans and trucks, remains the UK’s highest carbon-emitting sector and one of the slowest to decarbonise.

Read in depth: Politics

What this story rests on

2 sources from 2 organisations: 1 broadcaster, 1 newspaper or magazine.

  1. 1Climate advisers warn UK ministers: Don’t meddle with electric vehicle rulesPOLITICO · politico.euNewspaper or magazine
  2. 2Cutting EV target risks UK missing climate targets, warns adviserBBC News · bbc.co.ukBroadcaster

AI-assisted article checked against the listed sources. NewsJaws did not conduct interviews or attend the reported events.

Researched and drafted with AI tools from these sources, then checked against them paragraph by paragraph before publication. How we work · Everyone we cite · Report an error

Topics in this story

Add NewsJaws as a preferred source on Google

About NewsJaws Desk

AI-assisted reporting and explainers reviewed against the linked source documents. No claim of on-scene reporting or original interviews.

More from NewsJaws Desk

More from Politics

See all