AINews

John Swinney apologises over SNP’s Grand Theft Auto-style AI video

The Scottish first minister said he was sorry if the deleted video offended people, as he faced questions at Holyrood about AI’s effects on workers and the environment.

John Swinney in a dark suit and purple tie, standing indoors with a Scottish flag behind him.
John Swinney poses indoors for a portrait in 2024. File photograph. John Swinney - First Minister (53720492021) — Scottish Government, ‘John Swinney - First Minister’ (resized and converted to WebP). CC BY 2.0.Image sourceImage licence: CC BY 2.0
WhatsAppXLinkedInEmail
Save for later

Scotland’s First Minister John Swinney apologised at Holyrood on 19 November after his Scottish National Party deleted an AI-created Grand Theft Auto-style video, saying he was sorry if it had offended anyone. The post prompted questions about the effects of artificial intelligence on artists, workers and the environment.

PA Media reported that screenshots of the Instagram clip, captioned “Grand Theft Alba”, showed figures resembling Boris Johnson and Margaret Thatcher. One image depicted Thatcher emptying a sack marked “Scottish oil money” into a barrel labelled “UK Treasury”. The party said it had deleted the post after consideration.

The video appeared as Grand Theft Auto 6 arrived nearly 13 years after the previous instalment. RNZ reported that New Zealand was among the first places where players could unlock Rockstar Games’ new release.

Why the SNP said it posted the video

An SNP spokesperson said the clip sought to celebrate a Scottish success story while drawing attention to political issues, including Scotland’s energy wealth, Andy Burnham’s independence polling and the rise of Reform.

The spokesperson said the party was discussing the legitimate use of AI and its limits. PA reported that the post was removed shortly after it appeared, following criticism of its use of the technology.

AI concerns raised at Holyrood

At First Minister’s Questions, Scottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay said the post had angered anti-AI campaigners. She asked whether Swinney understood concerns about his government’s approach to AI and the companies behind it, citing the potential impact of AI and data centres on artists, workers and the environment.

“If we’ve offended anybody about that, I’m sorry about that. It’s not my intention,” Swinney said. He said he shared concerns about AI as industries faced significant change, but also pointed to potential benefits.

Swinney said AI was helping the NHS identify cancer risk and could improve clinical practice. He added that risks associated with AI data centres would be explored in government guidance and that wider policy issues would also be considered.

Edinburgh protest over data centres

The exchange followed a march through Edinburgh on 14 November against the growth in applications for hyperscale data centres in Scotland. Campaigners have raised concerns about AI’s energy and water use and the threat to jobs; activists said the Scottish Government had failed to explain why the centres were needed.

PA reported that thousands marched down the Royal Mile and gathered outside the Scottish Parliament. More than 80 organisations and groups supported the demonstration, including community campaigners affected by local proposals, climate groups, trade unions, artists and anti-poverty charities.

Read in depth: AI

What this story rests on

2 sources from 2 organisations: 1 broadcaster, 1 newspaper or magazine.

  1. 1John Swinney apologises over Grand Theft Auto AI videoPA Media, via The Standard · standard.co.ukNewspaper or magazine
  2. 2Grand Theft Auto 6: How long does it take to play and what are reviews saying?RNZ · rnz.co.nzBroadcaster

AI-assisted article checked against the listed sources. NewsJaws did not conduct interviews or attend the reported events.

Researched and drafted with AI tools from these sources, then checked against them paragraph by paragraph before publication. How we work · Everyone we cite · Report an error

Topics in this story

Add NewsJaws as a preferred source on Google

About NewsJaws Desk

AI-assisted reporting and explainers reviewed against the linked source documents. No claim of on-scene reporting or original interviews.

More from NewsJaws Desk

More from AI

See all