Manchester United consider Howe and Nagelsmann as Carrick's future hangs in balance

Manchester United have explored Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann as potential replacements for Michael Carrick if they dismiss him, BBC Sport reported on Monday, 26 October. Carrick's future was under discussion at the club's Carrington training ground after a run of eight matches without a win; no decision to remove him was confirmed.

BBC Sport said both managers feature prominently among the candidates United have considered and are aware of the club's interest. It reported that multiple sources described Howe as fully open to joining if Carrick loses his job. The Guardian separately reported that contact had been made with Howe, who would be open to taking the post subject to negotiations.

Why Carrick's Manchester United job is in doubt

The Bournemouth defeat left United 16th in the Premier League, one point above the relegation zone, after two wins all season, The Guardian reported. It was their eighth consecutive match without a victory. Those results have intensified scrutiny of Carrick's position, but the discussions at Carrington had not established who would lead the side next.

Howe, Nagelsmann and the other candidates

The Guardian described Howe as Wilcox's preferred candidate if United make a change. Howe left Newcastle United in the summer and is unattached, according to The National. He previously took Bournemouth from the fourth tier to the Premier League and later led Newcastle to a League Cup title in 2025. His availability would avoid the compensation involved in hiring a manager under contract.

Nagelsmann is also out of work after leaving his role as Germany head coach following the World Cup, BBC Sport reported. The Guardian said United recruitment director Christopher Vivell regards him highly and is believed to have sounded him out. Vivell and Nagelsmann previously worked together at RB Leipzig, where Nagelsmann later led the team to Bundesliga finishes of third and second, The National reported.

BBC Sport also said United admire Aston Villa manager Unai Emery, although his contract would complicate a move. The Guardian reported that Villa would seek around £20m in compensation for him. Antonio Conte is interested in the United job, according to BBC Sport, which described him as available after leaving Napoli in May. These are potential options if United decide to replace Carrick; the club had not named a successor.