SportsNews

Republic of Ireland beat Israel 3–0 after squad votes to play Nations League match

Ireland's players voted by a ‘significant majority’ to take the field after one player withdrew. Three first-half goals settled the match in Debrecen, with a return fixture scheduled for 4 October.

NewsJaws DeskEditorial desk
4 min read
Republic of Ireland men’s football team at Aviva Stadium in 2011
File photograph of the Republic of Ireland men’s football team at Aviva Stadium, Dublin, during a match against Estonia on 15 November 2011. Sean MacEntee (resized and converted to WebP). CC BY 2.0.
LinkedInPostEmail
Save for later

The Republic of Ireland beat Israel 3–0 in Debrecen, Hungary, on Sunday, a day after the squad voted by a ‘significant majority’ to play the Nations League fixture. The vote followed a player's request to withdraw and settled whether the team would take the field for this match. It did not settle the wider objections to Ireland playing Israel or determine what will happen at the scheduled return fixture.

Troy Parrott, Adam Idah and Jack Moylan scored in the first half of the 27 September match. The result gave Ireland the sporting outcome its players had voted to pursue after a difficult discussion within the squad, while leaving the association's broader position on the two fixtures unchanged.

A squad decision before kick-off

FAI chief executive David Courell said on 26 September that a ‘significant majority’ of the squad had voted to play after a player asked to withdraw, according to Anadolu Agency. The account gives no vote tally. It also does not establish who took part in the vote or whether the player who withdrew voted, so the scale of support cannot be described more precisely than Courell did.

Head coach Heimir Hallgrimsson said the player subsequently withdrew, Anadolu reported. He described players and officials as weighing personal considerations against the interests of the national team. ‘Nobody is comfortable at the moment,’ he said, adding that there was no course of action everyone would agree with. The account places the vote amid disagreement within the squad without establishing each player's position.

Ireland's squad decision came after the Football Association of Ireland had already committed to fulfilling both Nations League fixtures against Israel. The association set out that position in June. For the earlier account of the players' decision and the different views around it, see our report on the squad's vote to go ahead with the Israel matches.

Three goals before half-time

Ireland took control early in Debrecen. Parrott opened the scoring after James Abankwah worked the ball down the right, according to The Guardian's report from the stadium. Idah then ran onto a pass from Moylan to double the lead. Moylan added the third in the 25th minute after driving into the box, giving Ireland a three-goal advantage before the interval.

The Guardian reported that Ireland's players wore black armbands and stared at the ground during Israel's national anthem. The teams did not exchange pennants or shake hands before kick-off. Those gestures took place against the dispute over the fixture; they should not be treated as a statement of every player's reason for voting or playing.

Israel improved briefly after the break, with substitute Dor Peretz drawing a save from Caoimhín Kelleher, but there were no further goals. Afterward, Hallgrimsson called the preceding days the toughest of his coaching career and said his players had represented themselves with dignity. Israel coach Ran Ben-Shimon said his side had failed mentally and tactically and needed to find energy for another game in a few days.

Why the fixtures remain contested

In its June statement, the FAI said it had asked UEFA to suspend the Israel Football Association from its competitions and acknowledged the suffering of civilians in Gaza. It nonetheless maintained its commitment to play. The association said that refusing a fixture would bring a forfeit and could lead to further disciplinary measures, including possible disqualification from the competition.

The FAI also said a refusal would cost Ireland six points and could affect its Nations League status, rankings and future qualification prospects. Those are the association's stated assessment of the consequences, rather than outcomes established by Sunday's result. The potential impact on clubs, development programmes and other Ireland teams was part of its explanation for fulfilling the fixtures.

The association's position received a separate endorsement in July. FAI delegates backed the board's approach to fulfilling the Nations League fixtures by 75 votes to 32, with three abstentions, The Irish Times reported. The board motion did not explicitly name Israel and followed the rejection of an earlier boycott motion as inadmissible under FAI rules. That delegates' vote and Saturday's squad vote were distinct decisions at different stages.

The return fixture is scheduled for 4 October. In June, the FAI said UEFA had approved its request to stage that match outside Ireland at a neutral venue behind closed doors, citing operational challenges to holding it at home. Sunday's win records the outcome of the first meeting; it gives no answer yet about the return match's result or how the objections to these fixtures will develop.

Read in depth: Sports

Scotland’s new manager says the absent midfielder can play in several positions, but wants to establish the team’s shape after a goalless Nations League opener.

4 min read

The Dutch rider was caught after attacking from distance in Montreal, then answered another move on the final lap before beating Kasia Niewiadoma in a two-rider sprint.

4 min read

Sources and context

AI-assisted article checked against the listed sources. NewsJaws did not conduct interviews or attend the reported events.

About NewsJaws Desk

AI-assisted reporting and explainers reviewed against the linked source documents. No claim of on-scene reporting or original interviews.

More from Sports